The Oxford classification of IgA nephropathy: Pathology definitions, correlations, and reproducibility

Ian S D Roberts, H. Terence Cook, Stéphan Troyanov, Charles E. Alpers, Alessandro Amore, Jonathan Barratt, Francois Berthoux, Stephen Bonsib, Jan A. Bruijn, Daniel C. Cattran, Rosanna Coppo, Vivette D'Agati, Giuseppe D'Amico, Steven Emancipator, Francesco Emma, John Feehally, Franco Ferrario, Fernando Custodio Fervenza, Sandrine Florquin, Agnes FogoColin C. Geddes, Hermann Josef Groene, Mark Haas, Andrew M. Herzenberg, Prue A. Hill, Ronald J. Hogg, Stephen I. Hsu, J. Charles Jennette, Kensuke Joh, Bruce A. Julian, Tetsuya Kawamura, Fernand M. Lai, Lei Shi Li, Philip K T Li, Zhi Hong Liu, Bruce MacKinnon, Sergio Mezzano, F. Paolo Schena, Yasuhiko Tomino, Patrick D. Walker, Haiyan Wang, Jan J. Weening, Nori Yoshikawa, Hong Zhang

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

536 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Pathological classifications in current use for the assessment of glomerular disease have been typically opinion-based and built on the expert assumptions of renal pathologists about lesions historically thought to be relevant to prognosis. Here we develop a unique approach for the pathological classification of a glomerular disease, IgA nephropathy, in which renal pathologists first undertook extensive iterative work to define pathologic variables with acceptable inter-observer reproducibility. Where groups of such features closely correlated, variables were further selected on the basis of least susceptibility to sampling error and ease of scoring in routine practice. This process identified six pathologic variables that could then be used to interrogate prognostic significance independent of the clinical data in IgA nephropathy (described in the accompanying article). These variables were (1) mesangial cellularity score; percentage of glomeruli showing (2) segmental sclerosis, (3) endocapillary hypercellularity, or (4) cellular/fibrocellular crescents; (5) percentage of interstitial fibrosis/tubular atrophy; and finally (6) arteriosclerosis score. Results for interobserver reproducibility of individual pathological features are likely applicable to other glomerulonephritides, but it is not known if the correlations between variables depend on the specific type of glomerular pathobiology. Variables identified in this study withstood rigorous pathology review and statistical testing and we recommend that they become a necessary part of pathology reports for IgA nephropathy. Our methodology, translating a strong evidence-based dataset into a working format, is a model for developing classifications of other types of renal disease.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)546-556
Number of pages11
JournalKidney International
Volume76
Issue number5
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 2009

Fingerprint

Immunoglobulin A
Pathology
Kidney
Selection Bias
Arteriosclerosis
Sclerosis
Glomerulonephritis
Reproducibility of Results
Atrophy
Fibrosis
Pathologists
Datasets

Keywords

  • Glomerulonephritis
  • IgA nephropathy
  • Oxford classification
  • Pathology
  • Renal failure

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Nephrology

Cite this

Roberts, I. S. D., Cook, H. T., Troyanov, S., Alpers, C. E., Amore, A., Barratt, J., ... Zhang, H. (2009). The Oxford classification of IgA nephropathy: Pathology definitions, correlations, and reproducibility. Kidney International, 76(5), 546-556. https://doi.org/10.1038/ki.2009.168

The Oxford classification of IgA nephropathy : Pathology definitions, correlations, and reproducibility. / Roberts, Ian S D; Cook, H. Terence; Troyanov, Stéphan; Alpers, Charles E.; Amore, Alessandro; Barratt, Jonathan; Berthoux, Francois; Bonsib, Stephen; Bruijn, Jan A.; Cattran, Daniel C.; Coppo, Rosanna; D'Agati, Vivette; D'Amico, Giuseppe; Emancipator, Steven; Emma, Francesco; Feehally, John; Ferrario, Franco; Fervenza, Fernando Custodio; Florquin, Sandrine; Fogo, Agnes; Geddes, Colin C.; Groene, Hermann Josef; Haas, Mark; Herzenberg, Andrew M.; Hill, Prue A.; Hogg, Ronald J.; Hsu, Stephen I.; Jennette, J. Charles; Joh, Kensuke; Julian, Bruce A.; Kawamura, Tetsuya; Lai, Fernand M.; Li, Lei Shi; Li, Philip K T; Liu, Zhi Hong; MacKinnon, Bruce; Mezzano, Sergio; Schena, F. Paolo; Tomino, Yasuhiko; Walker, Patrick D.; Wang, Haiyan; Weening, Jan J.; Yoshikawa, Nori; Zhang, Hong.

In: Kidney International, Vol. 76, No. 5, 09.2009, p. 546-556.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Roberts, ISD, Cook, HT, Troyanov, S, Alpers, CE, Amore, A, Barratt, J, Berthoux, F, Bonsib, S, Bruijn, JA, Cattran, DC, Coppo, R, D'Agati, V, D'Amico, G, Emancipator, S, Emma, F, Feehally, J, Ferrario, F, Fervenza, FC, Florquin, S, Fogo, A, Geddes, CC, Groene, HJ, Haas, M, Herzenberg, AM, Hill, PA, Hogg, RJ, Hsu, SI, Jennette, JC, Joh, K, Julian, BA, Kawamura, T, Lai, FM, Li, LS, Li, PKT, Liu, ZH, MacKinnon, B, Mezzano, S, Schena, FP, Tomino, Y, Walker, PD, Wang, H, Weening, JJ, Yoshikawa, N & Zhang, H 2009, 'The Oxford classification of IgA nephropathy: Pathology definitions, correlations, and reproducibility', Kidney International, vol. 76, no. 5, pp. 546-556. https://doi.org/10.1038/ki.2009.168
Roberts, Ian S D ; Cook, H. Terence ; Troyanov, Stéphan ; Alpers, Charles E. ; Amore, Alessandro ; Barratt, Jonathan ; Berthoux, Francois ; Bonsib, Stephen ; Bruijn, Jan A. ; Cattran, Daniel C. ; Coppo, Rosanna ; D'Agati, Vivette ; D'Amico, Giuseppe ; Emancipator, Steven ; Emma, Francesco ; Feehally, John ; Ferrario, Franco ; Fervenza, Fernando Custodio ; Florquin, Sandrine ; Fogo, Agnes ; Geddes, Colin C. ; Groene, Hermann Josef ; Haas, Mark ; Herzenberg, Andrew M. ; Hill, Prue A. ; Hogg, Ronald J. ; Hsu, Stephen I. ; Jennette, J. Charles ; Joh, Kensuke ; Julian, Bruce A. ; Kawamura, Tetsuya ; Lai, Fernand M. ; Li, Lei Shi ; Li, Philip K T ; Liu, Zhi Hong ; MacKinnon, Bruce ; Mezzano, Sergio ; Schena, F. Paolo ; Tomino, Yasuhiko ; Walker, Patrick D. ; Wang, Haiyan ; Weening, Jan J. ; Yoshikawa, Nori ; Zhang, Hong. / The Oxford classification of IgA nephropathy : Pathology definitions, correlations, and reproducibility. In: Kidney International. 2009 ; Vol. 76, No. 5. pp. 546-556.
@article{d3a96b35a35740e3a2ad140fc2132d8b,
title = "The Oxford classification of IgA nephropathy: Pathology definitions, correlations, and reproducibility",
abstract = "Pathological classifications in current use for the assessment of glomerular disease have been typically opinion-based and built on the expert assumptions of renal pathologists about lesions historically thought to be relevant to prognosis. Here we develop a unique approach for the pathological classification of a glomerular disease, IgA nephropathy, in which renal pathologists first undertook extensive iterative work to define pathologic variables with acceptable inter-observer reproducibility. Where groups of such features closely correlated, variables were further selected on the basis of least susceptibility to sampling error and ease of scoring in routine practice. This process identified six pathologic variables that could then be used to interrogate prognostic significance independent of the clinical data in IgA nephropathy (described in the accompanying article). These variables were (1) mesangial cellularity score; percentage of glomeruli showing (2) segmental sclerosis, (3) endocapillary hypercellularity, or (4) cellular/fibrocellular crescents; (5) percentage of interstitial fibrosis/tubular atrophy; and finally (6) arteriosclerosis score. Results for interobserver reproducibility of individual pathological features are likely applicable to other glomerulonephritides, but it is not known if the correlations between variables depend on the specific type of glomerular pathobiology. Variables identified in this study withstood rigorous pathology review and statistical testing and we recommend that they become a necessary part of pathology reports for IgA nephropathy. Our methodology, translating a strong evidence-based dataset into a working format, is a model for developing classifications of other types of renal disease.",
keywords = "Glomerulonephritis, IgA nephropathy, Oxford classification, Pathology, Renal failure",
author = "Roberts, {Ian S D} and Cook, {H. Terence} and St{\'e}phan Troyanov and Alpers, {Charles E.} and Alessandro Amore and Jonathan Barratt and Francois Berthoux and Stephen Bonsib and Bruijn, {Jan A.} and Cattran, {Daniel C.} and Rosanna Coppo and Vivette D'Agati and Giuseppe D'Amico and Steven Emancipator and Francesco Emma and John Feehally and Franco Ferrario and Fervenza, {Fernando Custodio} and Sandrine Florquin and Agnes Fogo and Geddes, {Colin C.} and Groene, {Hermann Josef} and Mark Haas and Herzenberg, {Andrew M.} and Hill, {Prue A.} and Hogg, {Ronald J.} and Hsu, {Stephen I.} and Jennette, {J. Charles} and Kensuke Joh and Julian, {Bruce A.} and Tetsuya Kawamura and Lai, {Fernand M.} and Li, {Lei Shi} and Li, {Philip K T} and Liu, {Zhi Hong} and Bruce MacKinnon and Sergio Mezzano and Schena, {F. Paolo} and Yasuhiko Tomino and Walker, {Patrick D.} and Haiyan Wang and Weening, {Jan J.} and Nori Yoshikawa and Hong Zhang",
year = "2009",
month = "9",
doi = "10.1038/ki.2009.168",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "76",
pages = "546--556",
journal = "Kidney International",
issn = "0085-2538",
publisher = "Nature Publishing Group",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Oxford classification of IgA nephropathy

T2 - Pathology definitions, correlations, and reproducibility

AU - Roberts, Ian S D

AU - Cook, H. Terence

AU - Troyanov, Stéphan

AU - Alpers, Charles E.

AU - Amore, Alessandro

AU - Barratt, Jonathan

AU - Berthoux, Francois

AU - Bonsib, Stephen

AU - Bruijn, Jan A.

AU - Cattran, Daniel C.

AU - Coppo, Rosanna

AU - D'Agati, Vivette

AU - D'Amico, Giuseppe

AU - Emancipator, Steven

AU - Emma, Francesco

AU - Feehally, John

AU - Ferrario, Franco

AU - Fervenza, Fernando Custodio

AU - Florquin, Sandrine

AU - Fogo, Agnes

AU - Geddes, Colin C.

AU - Groene, Hermann Josef

AU - Haas, Mark

AU - Herzenberg, Andrew M.

AU - Hill, Prue A.

AU - Hogg, Ronald J.

AU - Hsu, Stephen I.

AU - Jennette, J. Charles

AU - Joh, Kensuke

AU - Julian, Bruce A.

AU - Kawamura, Tetsuya

AU - Lai, Fernand M.

AU - Li, Lei Shi

AU - Li, Philip K T

AU - Liu, Zhi Hong

AU - MacKinnon, Bruce

AU - Mezzano, Sergio

AU - Schena, F. Paolo

AU - Tomino, Yasuhiko

AU - Walker, Patrick D.

AU - Wang, Haiyan

AU - Weening, Jan J.

AU - Yoshikawa, Nori

AU - Zhang, Hong

PY - 2009/9

Y1 - 2009/9

N2 - Pathological classifications in current use for the assessment of glomerular disease have been typically opinion-based and built on the expert assumptions of renal pathologists about lesions historically thought to be relevant to prognosis. Here we develop a unique approach for the pathological classification of a glomerular disease, IgA nephropathy, in which renal pathologists first undertook extensive iterative work to define pathologic variables with acceptable inter-observer reproducibility. Where groups of such features closely correlated, variables were further selected on the basis of least susceptibility to sampling error and ease of scoring in routine practice. This process identified six pathologic variables that could then be used to interrogate prognostic significance independent of the clinical data in IgA nephropathy (described in the accompanying article). These variables were (1) mesangial cellularity score; percentage of glomeruli showing (2) segmental sclerosis, (3) endocapillary hypercellularity, or (4) cellular/fibrocellular crescents; (5) percentage of interstitial fibrosis/tubular atrophy; and finally (6) arteriosclerosis score. Results for interobserver reproducibility of individual pathological features are likely applicable to other glomerulonephritides, but it is not known if the correlations between variables depend on the specific type of glomerular pathobiology. Variables identified in this study withstood rigorous pathology review and statistical testing and we recommend that they become a necessary part of pathology reports for IgA nephropathy. Our methodology, translating a strong evidence-based dataset into a working format, is a model for developing classifications of other types of renal disease.

AB - Pathological classifications in current use for the assessment of glomerular disease have been typically opinion-based and built on the expert assumptions of renal pathologists about lesions historically thought to be relevant to prognosis. Here we develop a unique approach for the pathological classification of a glomerular disease, IgA nephropathy, in which renal pathologists first undertook extensive iterative work to define pathologic variables with acceptable inter-observer reproducibility. Where groups of such features closely correlated, variables were further selected on the basis of least susceptibility to sampling error and ease of scoring in routine practice. This process identified six pathologic variables that could then be used to interrogate prognostic significance independent of the clinical data in IgA nephropathy (described in the accompanying article). These variables were (1) mesangial cellularity score; percentage of glomeruli showing (2) segmental sclerosis, (3) endocapillary hypercellularity, or (4) cellular/fibrocellular crescents; (5) percentage of interstitial fibrosis/tubular atrophy; and finally (6) arteriosclerosis score. Results for interobserver reproducibility of individual pathological features are likely applicable to other glomerulonephritides, but it is not known if the correlations between variables depend on the specific type of glomerular pathobiology. Variables identified in this study withstood rigorous pathology review and statistical testing and we recommend that they become a necessary part of pathology reports for IgA nephropathy. Our methodology, translating a strong evidence-based dataset into a working format, is a model for developing classifications of other types of renal disease.

KW - Glomerulonephritis

KW - IgA nephropathy

KW - Oxford classification

KW - Pathology

KW - Renal failure

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=68949206247&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=68949206247&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1038/ki.2009.168

DO - 10.1038/ki.2009.168

M3 - Article

C2 - 19571790

AN - SCOPUS:68949206247

VL - 76

SP - 546

EP - 556

JO - Kidney International

JF - Kidney International

SN - 0085-2538

IS - 5

ER -