Physician cost consciousness and use of low-value clinical services

Michael Grover, Neena Susan Abraham, Yu Hui Chang, Jon C Tilburt

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Purpose: Choosing WiselyTM engaged medical specialties, creating "top 5 lists" of low-value services. We describe primary care physicians' (PCPs') self-reported use of these services and perceived barriers to guideline adherence. We quantify physician cost consciousness and determine associations with use. Methods: PCP attendees of a continuing medical education conference completed a survey. For each Family Medicine Choosing Wisely behavior, participants reported clinical adherence. Likert scale items assessed perceived barriers. Low-value service frequency was the dependent variable. A validated Cost Consciousness Scale created the predictor variable. We hypothesized that participants with greater cost consciousness would report less frequent use of low-value services. Results: Of 199 PCP attendees, 143 (72%) participated. Papanicolaou test after hysterectomy was performed least (0.2 mean services performed/10 patients). Provider knowledge of sinusitis treatment guidelines was greatest but provided most frequently (3.9 mean services performed/10 patients). Practice related barriers were perceived most frequently for adhering to sinusitis treatment guidelines. Attitudinal barriers were greatest for avoiding osteoporosis screening in low risk patients. Greater cost consciousness was associated with less use of low-value services (P = .03), greater knowledge of guidelines (P = .001), and fewer perceived attitudinal and practice behavior-related barriers (P < .001 for each). Greater knowledge of guidelines was not associated with less use of low-value services (P = .58). Familiarity with Choosing Wisely was associated with both greater cost consciousness (P = .004) and less use of low-value services (P = .03). Conclusions: Greater PCP cost consciousness was associated with less use of low-value services. Interventions to decrease perceived barriers and increase cost consciousness, perhaps by increasing awareness of Choosing Wisely, may translate into improved performance.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)785-792
Number of pages8
JournalJournal of the American Board of Family Medicine
Volume29
Issue number6
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 1 2016

Fingerprint

Consciousness
Physicians
Costs and Cost Analysis
Guidelines
Sinusitis
Medicine
Guideline Adherence
Papanicolaou Test
Continuing Medical Education
Primary Care Physicians
Hysterectomy
Osteoporosis
Therapeutics

Keywords

  • Choice behavior
  • Family practice
  • Guideline adherence
  • Hysterectomy
  • Osteoporosis
  • Papanicolaou test
  • Physicians
  • Primary care
  • Self report
  • Sinusitis
  • Surveys and questionnaires

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health
  • Family Practice

Cite this

Physician cost consciousness and use of low-value clinical services. / Grover, Michael; Abraham, Neena Susan; Chang, Yu Hui; Tilburt, Jon C.

In: Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine, Vol. 29, No. 6, 01.11.2016, p. 785-792.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{4d91f606b1cc423eb9a5cc01b1a7a5d6,
title = "Physician cost consciousness and use of low-value clinical services",
abstract = "Purpose: Choosing WiselyTM engaged medical specialties, creating {"}top 5 lists{"} of low-value services. We describe primary care physicians' (PCPs') self-reported use of these services and perceived barriers to guideline adherence. We quantify physician cost consciousness and determine associations with use. Methods: PCP attendees of a continuing medical education conference completed a survey. For each Family Medicine Choosing Wisely behavior, participants reported clinical adherence. Likert scale items assessed perceived barriers. Low-value service frequency was the dependent variable. A validated Cost Consciousness Scale created the predictor variable. We hypothesized that participants with greater cost consciousness would report less frequent use of low-value services. Results: Of 199 PCP attendees, 143 (72{\%}) participated. Papanicolaou test after hysterectomy was performed least (0.2 mean services performed/10 patients). Provider knowledge of sinusitis treatment guidelines was greatest but provided most frequently (3.9 mean services performed/10 patients). Practice related barriers were perceived most frequently for adhering to sinusitis treatment guidelines. Attitudinal barriers were greatest for avoiding osteoporosis screening in low risk patients. Greater cost consciousness was associated with less use of low-value services (P = .03), greater knowledge of guidelines (P = .001), and fewer perceived attitudinal and practice behavior-related barriers (P < .001 for each). Greater knowledge of guidelines was not associated with less use of low-value services (P = .58). Familiarity with Choosing Wisely was associated with both greater cost consciousness (P = .004) and less use of low-value services (P = .03). Conclusions: Greater PCP cost consciousness was associated with less use of low-value services. Interventions to decrease perceived barriers and increase cost consciousness, perhaps by increasing awareness of Choosing Wisely, may translate into improved performance.",
keywords = "Choice behavior, Family practice, Guideline adherence, Hysterectomy, Osteoporosis, Papanicolaou test, Physicians, Primary care, Self report, Sinusitis, Surveys and questionnaires",
author = "Michael Grover and Abraham, {Neena Susan} and Chang, {Yu Hui} and Tilburt, {Jon C}",
year = "2016",
month = "11",
day = "1",
doi = "10.3122/jabfm.2016.06.160176",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "29",
pages = "785--792",
journal = "Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine",
issn = "1557-2625",
publisher = "American Board of Family Medicine",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Physician cost consciousness and use of low-value clinical services

AU - Grover, Michael

AU - Abraham, Neena Susan

AU - Chang, Yu Hui

AU - Tilburt, Jon C

PY - 2016/11/1

Y1 - 2016/11/1

N2 - Purpose: Choosing WiselyTM engaged medical specialties, creating "top 5 lists" of low-value services. We describe primary care physicians' (PCPs') self-reported use of these services and perceived barriers to guideline adherence. We quantify physician cost consciousness and determine associations with use. Methods: PCP attendees of a continuing medical education conference completed a survey. For each Family Medicine Choosing Wisely behavior, participants reported clinical adherence. Likert scale items assessed perceived barriers. Low-value service frequency was the dependent variable. A validated Cost Consciousness Scale created the predictor variable. We hypothesized that participants with greater cost consciousness would report less frequent use of low-value services. Results: Of 199 PCP attendees, 143 (72%) participated. Papanicolaou test after hysterectomy was performed least (0.2 mean services performed/10 patients). Provider knowledge of sinusitis treatment guidelines was greatest but provided most frequently (3.9 mean services performed/10 patients). Practice related barriers were perceived most frequently for adhering to sinusitis treatment guidelines. Attitudinal barriers were greatest for avoiding osteoporosis screening in low risk patients. Greater cost consciousness was associated with less use of low-value services (P = .03), greater knowledge of guidelines (P = .001), and fewer perceived attitudinal and practice behavior-related barriers (P < .001 for each). Greater knowledge of guidelines was not associated with less use of low-value services (P = .58). Familiarity with Choosing Wisely was associated with both greater cost consciousness (P = .004) and less use of low-value services (P = .03). Conclusions: Greater PCP cost consciousness was associated with less use of low-value services. Interventions to decrease perceived barriers and increase cost consciousness, perhaps by increasing awareness of Choosing Wisely, may translate into improved performance.

AB - Purpose: Choosing WiselyTM engaged medical specialties, creating "top 5 lists" of low-value services. We describe primary care physicians' (PCPs') self-reported use of these services and perceived barriers to guideline adherence. We quantify physician cost consciousness and determine associations with use. Methods: PCP attendees of a continuing medical education conference completed a survey. For each Family Medicine Choosing Wisely behavior, participants reported clinical adherence. Likert scale items assessed perceived barriers. Low-value service frequency was the dependent variable. A validated Cost Consciousness Scale created the predictor variable. We hypothesized that participants with greater cost consciousness would report less frequent use of low-value services. Results: Of 199 PCP attendees, 143 (72%) participated. Papanicolaou test after hysterectomy was performed least (0.2 mean services performed/10 patients). Provider knowledge of sinusitis treatment guidelines was greatest but provided most frequently (3.9 mean services performed/10 patients). Practice related barriers were perceived most frequently for adhering to sinusitis treatment guidelines. Attitudinal barriers were greatest for avoiding osteoporosis screening in low risk patients. Greater cost consciousness was associated with less use of low-value services (P = .03), greater knowledge of guidelines (P = .001), and fewer perceived attitudinal and practice behavior-related barriers (P < .001 for each). Greater knowledge of guidelines was not associated with less use of low-value services (P = .58). Familiarity with Choosing Wisely was associated with both greater cost consciousness (P = .004) and less use of low-value services (P = .03). Conclusions: Greater PCP cost consciousness was associated with less use of low-value services. Interventions to decrease perceived barriers and increase cost consciousness, perhaps by increasing awareness of Choosing Wisely, may translate into improved performance.

KW - Choice behavior

KW - Family practice

KW - Guideline adherence

KW - Hysterectomy

KW - Osteoporosis

KW - Papanicolaou test

KW - Physicians

KW - Primary care

KW - Self report

KW - Sinusitis

KW - Surveys and questionnaires

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84995676277&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84995676277&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3122/jabfm.2016.06.160176

DO - 10.3122/jabfm.2016.06.160176

M3 - Article

C2 - 28076262

AN - SCOPUS:84995676277

VL - 29

SP - 785

EP - 792

JO - Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine

JF - Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine

SN - 1557-2625

IS - 6

ER -