Managing incidental findings in human subjects research: Analysis and recommendations

Susan M. Wolf, Frances P. Lawrenz, Charles A. Nelson, Jeffrey P. Kahn, Mildred K. Cho, Ellen Wright Clayton, Joel Garland Fletcher, Michael K. Georgieff, Dale Hammerschmidt, Kathy Hudson, Judy Illes, Vivek Kapur, Moira A. Keane, Barbara A. Koenig, Bonnie S. LeRoy, Elizabeth G. McFarland, Jordan Paradise, Lisa S. Parker, Sharon F. Terry, Brian Van NessBenjamin S. Wilfond

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

470 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

No consensus yet exists on how to handle incidental fnd-ings (IFs) in human subjects research. Yet empirical studies document IFs in a wide range of research studies, where IFs are fndings beyond the aims of the study that are of potential health or reproductive importance to the individual research participant. This paper reports recommendations of a two-year project group funded by NIH to study how to manage IFs in genetic and genomic research, as well as imaging research. We conclude that researchers have an obligation to address the possibility of discovering IFs in their protocol and communications with the IRB, and in their consent forms and communications with research participants. Researchers should establish a pathway for handling IFs and communicate that to the IRB and research participants. We recommend a pathway and categorize IFs into those that must be disclosed to research participants, those that may be disclosed, and those that should not be disclosed.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)219-248
Number of pages30
JournalJournal of Law, Medicine and Ethics
Volume36
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Jun 2008

Fingerprint

Incidental Findings
Research
Research Ethics Committees
Communication
Research Personnel
communications
Consent Forms
Genetic Research
Reproductive Health
project group
Consensus
obligation
health

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Law
  • Medicine (miscellaneous)

Cite this

Wolf, S. M., Lawrenz, F. P., Nelson, C. A., Kahn, J. P., Cho, M. K., Clayton, E. W., ... Wilfond, B. S. (2008). Managing incidental findings in human subjects research: Analysis and recommendations. Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics, 36(2), 219-248. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-720X.2008.00266.x

Managing incidental findings in human subjects research : Analysis and recommendations. / Wolf, Susan M.; Lawrenz, Frances P.; Nelson, Charles A.; Kahn, Jeffrey P.; Cho, Mildred K.; Clayton, Ellen Wright; Fletcher, Joel Garland; Georgieff, Michael K.; Hammerschmidt, Dale; Hudson, Kathy; Illes, Judy; Kapur, Vivek; Keane, Moira A.; Koenig, Barbara A.; LeRoy, Bonnie S.; McFarland, Elizabeth G.; Paradise, Jordan; Parker, Lisa S.; Terry, Sharon F.; Van Ness, Brian; Wilfond, Benjamin S.

In: Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics, Vol. 36, No. 2, 06.2008, p. 219-248.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Wolf, SM, Lawrenz, FP, Nelson, CA, Kahn, JP, Cho, MK, Clayton, EW, Fletcher, JG, Georgieff, MK, Hammerschmidt, D, Hudson, K, Illes, J, Kapur, V, Keane, MA, Koenig, BA, LeRoy, BS, McFarland, EG, Paradise, J, Parker, LS, Terry, SF, Van Ness, B & Wilfond, BS 2008, 'Managing incidental findings in human subjects research: Analysis and recommendations', Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics, vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 219-248. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-720X.2008.00266.x
Wolf, Susan M. ; Lawrenz, Frances P. ; Nelson, Charles A. ; Kahn, Jeffrey P. ; Cho, Mildred K. ; Clayton, Ellen Wright ; Fletcher, Joel Garland ; Georgieff, Michael K. ; Hammerschmidt, Dale ; Hudson, Kathy ; Illes, Judy ; Kapur, Vivek ; Keane, Moira A. ; Koenig, Barbara A. ; LeRoy, Bonnie S. ; McFarland, Elizabeth G. ; Paradise, Jordan ; Parker, Lisa S. ; Terry, Sharon F. ; Van Ness, Brian ; Wilfond, Benjamin S. / Managing incidental findings in human subjects research : Analysis and recommendations. In: Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics. 2008 ; Vol. 36, No. 2. pp. 219-248.
@article{30f1a19d8daf465e90532199f81b65a6,
title = "Managing incidental findings in human subjects research: Analysis and recommendations",
abstract = "No consensus yet exists on how to handle incidental fnd-ings (IFs) in human subjects research. Yet empirical studies document IFs in a wide range of research studies, where IFs are fndings beyond the aims of the study that are of potential health or reproductive importance to the individual research participant. This paper reports recommendations of a two-year project group funded by NIH to study how to manage IFs in genetic and genomic research, as well as imaging research. We conclude that researchers have an obligation to address the possibility of discovering IFs in their protocol and communications with the IRB, and in their consent forms and communications with research participants. Researchers should establish a pathway for handling IFs and communicate that to the IRB and research participants. We recommend a pathway and categorize IFs into those that must be disclosed to research participants, those that may be disclosed, and those that should not be disclosed.",
author = "Wolf, {Susan M.} and Lawrenz, {Frances P.} and Nelson, {Charles A.} and Kahn, {Jeffrey P.} and Cho, {Mildred K.} and Clayton, {Ellen Wright} and Fletcher, {Joel Garland} and Georgieff, {Michael K.} and Dale Hammerschmidt and Kathy Hudson and Judy Illes and Vivek Kapur and Keane, {Moira A.} and Koenig, {Barbara A.} and LeRoy, {Bonnie S.} and McFarland, {Elizabeth G.} and Jordan Paradise and Parker, {Lisa S.} and Terry, {Sharon F.} and {Van Ness}, Brian and Wilfond, {Benjamin S.}",
year = "2008",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1111/j.1748-720X.2008.00266.x",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "36",
pages = "219--248",
journal = "Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics",
issn = "1073-1105",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Managing incidental findings in human subjects research

T2 - Analysis and recommendations

AU - Wolf, Susan M.

AU - Lawrenz, Frances P.

AU - Nelson, Charles A.

AU - Kahn, Jeffrey P.

AU - Cho, Mildred K.

AU - Clayton, Ellen Wright

AU - Fletcher, Joel Garland

AU - Georgieff, Michael K.

AU - Hammerschmidt, Dale

AU - Hudson, Kathy

AU - Illes, Judy

AU - Kapur, Vivek

AU - Keane, Moira A.

AU - Koenig, Barbara A.

AU - LeRoy, Bonnie S.

AU - McFarland, Elizabeth G.

AU - Paradise, Jordan

AU - Parker, Lisa S.

AU - Terry, Sharon F.

AU - Van Ness, Brian

AU - Wilfond, Benjamin S.

PY - 2008/6

Y1 - 2008/6

N2 - No consensus yet exists on how to handle incidental fnd-ings (IFs) in human subjects research. Yet empirical studies document IFs in a wide range of research studies, where IFs are fndings beyond the aims of the study that are of potential health or reproductive importance to the individual research participant. This paper reports recommendations of a two-year project group funded by NIH to study how to manage IFs in genetic and genomic research, as well as imaging research. We conclude that researchers have an obligation to address the possibility of discovering IFs in their protocol and communications with the IRB, and in their consent forms and communications with research participants. Researchers should establish a pathway for handling IFs and communicate that to the IRB and research participants. We recommend a pathway and categorize IFs into those that must be disclosed to research participants, those that may be disclosed, and those that should not be disclosed.

AB - No consensus yet exists on how to handle incidental fnd-ings (IFs) in human subjects research. Yet empirical studies document IFs in a wide range of research studies, where IFs are fndings beyond the aims of the study that are of potential health or reproductive importance to the individual research participant. This paper reports recommendations of a two-year project group funded by NIH to study how to manage IFs in genetic and genomic research, as well as imaging research. We conclude that researchers have an obligation to address the possibility of discovering IFs in their protocol and communications with the IRB, and in their consent forms and communications with research participants. Researchers should establish a pathway for handling IFs and communicate that to the IRB and research participants. We recommend a pathway and categorize IFs into those that must be disclosed to research participants, those that may be disclosed, and those that should not be disclosed.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=44949211505&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=44949211505&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/j.1748-720X.2008.00266.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1748-720X.2008.00266.x

M3 - Article

C2 - 18547191

AN - SCOPUS:44949211505

VL - 36

SP - 219

EP - 248

JO - Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics

JF - Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics

SN - 1073-1105

IS - 2

ER -