Managing incidental findings and research results in genomic research involving biobanks and archived data sets

Susan M. Wolf, Brittney N. Crock, Brian Van Ness, Frances Lawrenz, Jeffrey P. Kahn, Laura M. Beskow, Mildred K. Cho, Michael F. Christman, Robert C. Green, Ralph Hall, Judy Illes, Moira Keane, Bartha M. Knoppers, Barbara A. Koenig, Isaac S. Kohane, Bonnie Leroy, Karen J. Maschke, William McGeveran, Pilar Ossorio, Lisa S. ParkerGloria M Petersen, Henry S. Richardson, Joan A. Scott, Sharon F. Terry, Benjamin S. Wilfond, Wendy A. Wolf

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

301 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Biobanks and archived data sets collecting samples and data have become crucial engines of genetic and genomic research. Unresolved, however, is what responsibilities biobanks should shoulder to manage incidental findings and individual research results of potential health, reproductive, or personal importance to individual contributors (using "biobank" here to refer both to collections of samples and collections of data). This article reports recommendations from a 2-year project funded by the National Institutes of Health. We analyze the responsibilities involved in managing the return of incidental findings and individual research results in a biobank research system (primary research or collection sites, the biobank itself, and secondary research sites). We suggest that biobanks shoulder significant responsibility for seeing that the biobank research system addresses the return question explicitly. When reidentification of individual contributors is possible, the biobank should work to enable the biobank research system to discharge four core responsibilities to (1) clarify the criteria for evaluating findings and the roster of returnable findings, (2) analyze a particular finding in relation to this, (3) reidentify the individual contributor, and (4) recontact the contributor to offer the finding. We suggest that findings that are analytically valid, reveal an established and substantial risk of a serious health condition, and are clinically actionable should generally be offered to consenting contributors. This article specifies 10 concrete recommendations, addressing new biobanks as well as those already in existence.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)361-384
Number of pages24
JournalGenetics in Medicine
Volume14
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 2012

Fingerprint

Incidental Findings
Research
Duty to Recontact
Genetic Research
Reproductive Health
National Institutes of Health (U.S.)
Datasets
Health

Keywords

  • biobanks
  • bioethics
  • genetics
  • genomics
  • incidental findings
  • research ethics
  • return of results

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Genetics(clinical)

Cite this

Wolf, S. M., Crock, B. N., Van Ness, B., Lawrenz, F., Kahn, J. P., Beskow, L. M., ... Wolf, W. A. (2012). Managing incidental findings and research results in genomic research involving biobanks and archived data sets. Genetics in Medicine, 14(4), 361-384. https://doi.org/10.1038/gim.2012.23

Managing incidental findings and research results in genomic research involving biobanks and archived data sets. / Wolf, Susan M.; Crock, Brittney N.; Van Ness, Brian; Lawrenz, Frances; Kahn, Jeffrey P.; Beskow, Laura M.; Cho, Mildred K.; Christman, Michael F.; Green, Robert C.; Hall, Ralph; Illes, Judy; Keane, Moira; Knoppers, Bartha M.; Koenig, Barbara A.; Kohane, Isaac S.; Leroy, Bonnie; Maschke, Karen J.; McGeveran, William; Ossorio, Pilar; Parker, Lisa S.; Petersen, Gloria M; Richardson, Henry S.; Scott, Joan A.; Terry, Sharon F.; Wilfond, Benjamin S.; Wolf, Wendy A.

In: Genetics in Medicine, Vol. 14, No. 4, 04.2012, p. 361-384.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Wolf, SM, Crock, BN, Van Ness, B, Lawrenz, F, Kahn, JP, Beskow, LM, Cho, MK, Christman, MF, Green, RC, Hall, R, Illes, J, Keane, M, Knoppers, BM, Koenig, BA, Kohane, IS, Leroy, B, Maschke, KJ, McGeveran, W, Ossorio, P, Parker, LS, Petersen, GM, Richardson, HS, Scott, JA, Terry, SF, Wilfond, BS & Wolf, WA 2012, 'Managing incidental findings and research results in genomic research involving biobanks and archived data sets', Genetics in Medicine, vol. 14, no. 4, pp. 361-384. https://doi.org/10.1038/gim.2012.23
Wolf, Susan M. ; Crock, Brittney N. ; Van Ness, Brian ; Lawrenz, Frances ; Kahn, Jeffrey P. ; Beskow, Laura M. ; Cho, Mildred K. ; Christman, Michael F. ; Green, Robert C. ; Hall, Ralph ; Illes, Judy ; Keane, Moira ; Knoppers, Bartha M. ; Koenig, Barbara A. ; Kohane, Isaac S. ; Leroy, Bonnie ; Maschke, Karen J. ; McGeveran, William ; Ossorio, Pilar ; Parker, Lisa S. ; Petersen, Gloria M ; Richardson, Henry S. ; Scott, Joan A. ; Terry, Sharon F. ; Wilfond, Benjamin S. ; Wolf, Wendy A. / Managing incidental findings and research results in genomic research involving biobanks and archived data sets. In: Genetics in Medicine. 2012 ; Vol. 14, No. 4. pp. 361-384.
@article{0bf45bd0252d45a1a7a6a1c833e4ea26,
title = "Managing incidental findings and research results in genomic research involving biobanks and archived data sets",
abstract = "Biobanks and archived data sets collecting samples and data have become crucial engines of genetic and genomic research. Unresolved, however, is what responsibilities biobanks should shoulder to manage incidental findings and individual research results of potential health, reproductive, or personal importance to individual contributors (using {"}biobank{"} here to refer both to collections of samples and collections of data). This article reports recommendations from a 2-year project funded by the National Institutes of Health. We analyze the responsibilities involved in managing the return of incidental findings and individual research results in a biobank research system (primary research or collection sites, the biobank itself, and secondary research sites). We suggest that biobanks shoulder significant responsibility for seeing that the biobank research system addresses the return question explicitly. When reidentification of individual contributors is possible, the biobank should work to enable the biobank research system to discharge four core responsibilities to (1) clarify the criteria for evaluating findings and the roster of returnable findings, (2) analyze a particular finding in relation to this, (3) reidentify the individual contributor, and (4) recontact the contributor to offer the finding. We suggest that findings that are analytically valid, reveal an established and substantial risk of a serious health condition, and are clinically actionable should generally be offered to consenting contributors. This article specifies 10 concrete recommendations, addressing new biobanks as well as those already in existence.",
keywords = "biobanks, bioethics, genetics, genomics, incidental findings, research ethics, return of results",
author = "Wolf, {Susan M.} and Crock, {Brittney N.} and {Van Ness}, Brian and Frances Lawrenz and Kahn, {Jeffrey P.} and Beskow, {Laura M.} and Cho, {Mildred K.} and Christman, {Michael F.} and Green, {Robert C.} and Ralph Hall and Judy Illes and Moira Keane and Knoppers, {Bartha M.} and Koenig, {Barbara A.} and Kohane, {Isaac S.} and Bonnie Leroy and Maschke, {Karen J.} and William McGeveran and Pilar Ossorio and Parker, {Lisa S.} and Petersen, {Gloria M} and Richardson, {Henry S.} and Scott, {Joan A.} and Terry, {Sharon F.} and Wilfond, {Benjamin S.} and Wolf, {Wendy A.}",
year = "2012",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1038/gim.2012.23",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "14",
pages = "361--384",
journal = "Genetics in Medicine",
issn = "1098-3600",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams and Wilkins",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Managing incidental findings and research results in genomic research involving biobanks and archived data sets

AU - Wolf, Susan M.

AU - Crock, Brittney N.

AU - Van Ness, Brian

AU - Lawrenz, Frances

AU - Kahn, Jeffrey P.

AU - Beskow, Laura M.

AU - Cho, Mildred K.

AU - Christman, Michael F.

AU - Green, Robert C.

AU - Hall, Ralph

AU - Illes, Judy

AU - Keane, Moira

AU - Knoppers, Bartha M.

AU - Koenig, Barbara A.

AU - Kohane, Isaac S.

AU - Leroy, Bonnie

AU - Maschke, Karen J.

AU - McGeveran, William

AU - Ossorio, Pilar

AU - Parker, Lisa S.

AU - Petersen, Gloria M

AU - Richardson, Henry S.

AU - Scott, Joan A.

AU - Terry, Sharon F.

AU - Wilfond, Benjamin S.

AU - Wolf, Wendy A.

PY - 2012/4

Y1 - 2012/4

N2 - Biobanks and archived data sets collecting samples and data have become crucial engines of genetic and genomic research. Unresolved, however, is what responsibilities biobanks should shoulder to manage incidental findings and individual research results of potential health, reproductive, or personal importance to individual contributors (using "biobank" here to refer both to collections of samples and collections of data). This article reports recommendations from a 2-year project funded by the National Institutes of Health. We analyze the responsibilities involved in managing the return of incidental findings and individual research results in a biobank research system (primary research or collection sites, the biobank itself, and secondary research sites). We suggest that biobanks shoulder significant responsibility for seeing that the biobank research system addresses the return question explicitly. When reidentification of individual contributors is possible, the biobank should work to enable the biobank research system to discharge four core responsibilities to (1) clarify the criteria for evaluating findings and the roster of returnable findings, (2) analyze a particular finding in relation to this, (3) reidentify the individual contributor, and (4) recontact the contributor to offer the finding. We suggest that findings that are analytically valid, reveal an established and substantial risk of a serious health condition, and are clinically actionable should generally be offered to consenting contributors. This article specifies 10 concrete recommendations, addressing new biobanks as well as those already in existence.

AB - Biobanks and archived data sets collecting samples and data have become crucial engines of genetic and genomic research. Unresolved, however, is what responsibilities biobanks should shoulder to manage incidental findings and individual research results of potential health, reproductive, or personal importance to individual contributors (using "biobank" here to refer both to collections of samples and collections of data). This article reports recommendations from a 2-year project funded by the National Institutes of Health. We analyze the responsibilities involved in managing the return of incidental findings and individual research results in a biobank research system (primary research or collection sites, the biobank itself, and secondary research sites). We suggest that biobanks shoulder significant responsibility for seeing that the biobank research system addresses the return question explicitly. When reidentification of individual contributors is possible, the biobank should work to enable the biobank research system to discharge four core responsibilities to (1) clarify the criteria for evaluating findings and the roster of returnable findings, (2) analyze a particular finding in relation to this, (3) reidentify the individual contributor, and (4) recontact the contributor to offer the finding. We suggest that findings that are analytically valid, reveal an established and substantial risk of a serious health condition, and are clinically actionable should generally be offered to consenting contributors. This article specifies 10 concrete recommendations, addressing new biobanks as well as those already in existence.

KW - biobanks

KW - bioethics

KW - genetics

KW - genomics

KW - incidental findings

KW - research ethics

KW - return of results

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84859566974&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84859566974&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1038/gim.2012.23

DO - 10.1038/gim.2012.23

M3 - Article

C2 - 22436882

AN - SCOPUS:84859566974

VL - 14

SP - 361

EP - 384

JO - Genetics in Medicine

JF - Genetics in Medicine

SN - 1098-3600

IS - 4

ER -