Intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder formation: Why not to do it?

Kassem S. Faraj, Haidar M. Abdul-Muhsin, Anojan K. Navaratnam, Kyle M. Rose, Erik P Castle

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

OBJECTIVES: There has been growing  interest in intracorporeal techniques to urinary diversion during cystectomy in the modern area. There is little high-quality evidence that this technique is superior to  extracorporeal diversion in patients who are obtaining  an orthotopic intracorporeal neobladder urinary diversion. This study describes the proposed advantages and  disadvantages of intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder urinary diversion and expert opinion on preference. METHODS: We reviewed the literature for all studies  discussing the outcomes and advantages of intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder urinary diversion, including those comparing the intracorporeal and extracorporeal approach. The studies were reviewed and these findings were summarized based on categories of the proposed advantages and disadvantages of the intracorporeal approach. We provided an assessment of the claims made in favor of the intracorporeal approach and discussed advantages of the extracorporeal approach that may persuade even the most experienced robotic surgeons to lean away from the former. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: Herein we review the studies that propose advantages of the intracorporeal diversion, as well as the studies that do not demonstrate any advantage to this approach. Some of the proposedadvantages addressed include decreased stricture rate, lower complications and shorter hospitalization. Furthermore, we address the issues of the steep learningcurve and the impact on resident education. We conclude that the proposed benefits of an intracorporeal approach to urinary diversion are not substantiated and it is the preference of the authors to primarily perform extracorporeal urinary diversions.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)318-325
Number of pages8
JournalArchivos espanoles de urologia
Volume72
Issue number3
StatePublished - Apr 1 2019

Fingerprint

Urinary Diversion
Cystectomy
Expert Testimony
Robotics
Pathologic Constriction
Hospitalization
Outcome Assessment (Health Care)
Education

Keywords

  • Cistectomía
  • Cystectomy
  • Derivación urinaria
  • Extracorporeal
  • Extracorpórea
  • Intracorporeal
  • Intracorpórea
  • Procedimientos quirúrgicos
  • Robotic
  • Robótica
  • Surgical Procedures
  • Urinary diversion

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Urology

Cite this

Faraj, K. S., Abdul-Muhsin, H. M., Navaratnam, A. K., Rose, K. M., & Castle, E. P. (2019). Intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder formation: Why not to do it? Archivos espanoles de urologia, 72(3), 318-325.

Intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder formation : Why not to do it? / Faraj, Kassem S.; Abdul-Muhsin, Haidar M.; Navaratnam, Anojan K.; Rose, Kyle M.; Castle, Erik P.

In: Archivos espanoles de urologia, Vol. 72, No. 3, 01.04.2019, p. 318-325.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Faraj, KS, Abdul-Muhsin, HM, Navaratnam, AK, Rose, KM & Castle, EP 2019, 'Intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder formation: Why not to do it?', Archivos espanoles de urologia, vol. 72, no. 3, pp. 318-325.
Faraj KS, Abdul-Muhsin HM, Navaratnam AK, Rose KM, Castle EP. Intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder formation: Why not to do it? Archivos espanoles de urologia. 2019 Apr 1;72(3):318-325.
Faraj, Kassem S. ; Abdul-Muhsin, Haidar M. ; Navaratnam, Anojan K. ; Rose, Kyle M. ; Castle, Erik P. / Intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder formation : Why not to do it?. In: Archivos espanoles de urologia. 2019 ; Vol. 72, No. 3. pp. 318-325.
@article{b8b70d02cfc047fda0a98659cae4dc07,
title = "Intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder formation: Why not to do it?",
abstract = "OBJECTIVES: There has been growing  interest in intracorporeal techniques to urinary diversion during cystectomy in the modern area. There is little high-quality evidence that this technique is superior to  extracorporeal diversion in patients who are obtaining  an orthotopic intracorporeal neobladder urinary diversion. This study describes the proposed advantages and  disadvantages of intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder urinary diversion and expert opinion on preference. METHODS: We reviewed the literature for all studies  discussing the outcomes and advantages of intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder urinary diversion, including those comparing the intracorporeal and extracorporeal approach. The studies were reviewed and these findings were summarized based on categories of the proposed advantages and disadvantages of the intracorporeal approach. We provided an assessment of the claims made in favor of the intracorporeal approach and discussed advantages of the extracorporeal approach that may persuade even the most experienced robotic surgeons to lean away from the former. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: Herein we review the studies that propose advantages of the intracorporeal diversion, as well as the studies that do not demonstrate any advantage to this approach. Some of the proposedadvantages addressed include decreased stricture rate, lower complications and shorter hospitalization. Furthermore, we address the issues of the steep learningcurve and the impact on resident education. We conclude that the proposed benefits of an intracorporeal approach to urinary diversion are not substantiated and it is the preference of the authors to primarily perform extracorporeal urinary diversions.",
keywords = "Cistectom{\'i}a, Cystectomy, Derivaci{\'o}n urinaria, Extracorporeal, Extracorp{\'o}rea, Intracorporeal, Intracorp{\'o}rea, Procedimientos quir{\'u}rgicos, Robotic, Rob{\'o}tica, Surgical Procedures, Urinary diversion",
author = "Faraj, {Kassem S.} and Abdul-Muhsin, {Haidar M.} and Navaratnam, {Anojan K.} and Rose, {Kyle M.} and Castle, {Erik P}",
year = "2019",
month = "4",
day = "1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "72",
pages = "318--325",
journal = "Archivos Espanoles de Urologia",
issn = "0004-0614",
publisher = "Iniestares, S.A.",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder formation

T2 - Why not to do it?

AU - Faraj, Kassem S.

AU - Abdul-Muhsin, Haidar M.

AU - Navaratnam, Anojan K.

AU - Rose, Kyle M.

AU - Castle, Erik P

PY - 2019/4/1

Y1 - 2019/4/1

N2 - OBJECTIVES: There has been growing  interest in intracorporeal techniques to urinary diversion during cystectomy in the modern area. There is little high-quality evidence that this technique is superior to  extracorporeal diversion in patients who are obtaining  an orthotopic intracorporeal neobladder urinary diversion. This study describes the proposed advantages and  disadvantages of intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder urinary diversion and expert opinion on preference. METHODS: We reviewed the literature for all studies  discussing the outcomes and advantages of intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder urinary diversion, including those comparing the intracorporeal and extracorporeal approach. The studies were reviewed and these findings were summarized based on categories of the proposed advantages and disadvantages of the intracorporeal approach. We provided an assessment of the claims made in favor of the intracorporeal approach and discussed advantages of the extracorporeal approach that may persuade even the most experienced robotic surgeons to lean away from the former. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: Herein we review the studies that propose advantages of the intracorporeal diversion, as well as the studies that do not demonstrate any advantage to this approach. Some of the proposedadvantages addressed include decreased stricture rate, lower complications and shorter hospitalization. Furthermore, we address the issues of the steep learningcurve and the impact on resident education. We conclude that the proposed benefits of an intracorporeal approach to urinary diversion are not substantiated and it is the preference of the authors to primarily perform extracorporeal urinary diversions.

AB - OBJECTIVES: There has been growing  interest in intracorporeal techniques to urinary diversion during cystectomy in the modern area. There is little high-quality evidence that this technique is superior to  extracorporeal diversion in patients who are obtaining  an orthotopic intracorporeal neobladder urinary diversion. This study describes the proposed advantages and  disadvantages of intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder urinary diversion and expert opinion on preference. METHODS: We reviewed the literature for all studies  discussing the outcomes and advantages of intracorporeal orthotopic neobladder urinary diversion, including those comparing the intracorporeal and extracorporeal approach. The studies were reviewed and these findings were summarized based on categories of the proposed advantages and disadvantages of the intracorporeal approach. We provided an assessment of the claims made in favor of the intracorporeal approach and discussed advantages of the extracorporeal approach that may persuade even the most experienced robotic surgeons to lean away from the former. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: Herein we review the studies that propose advantages of the intracorporeal diversion, as well as the studies that do not demonstrate any advantage to this approach. Some of the proposedadvantages addressed include decreased stricture rate, lower complications and shorter hospitalization. Furthermore, we address the issues of the steep learningcurve and the impact on resident education. We conclude that the proposed benefits of an intracorporeal approach to urinary diversion are not substantiated and it is the preference of the authors to primarily perform extracorporeal urinary diversions.

KW - Cistectomía

KW - Cystectomy

KW - Derivación urinaria

KW - Extracorporeal

KW - Extracorpórea

KW - Intracorporeal

KW - Intracorpórea

KW - Procedimientos quirúrgicos

KW - Robotic

KW - Robótica

KW - Surgical Procedures

KW - Urinary diversion

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85064239204&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85064239204&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 30945659

AN - SCOPUS:85064239204

VL - 72

SP - 318

EP - 325

JO - Archivos Espanoles de Urologia

JF - Archivos Espanoles de Urologia

SN - 0004-0614

IS - 3

ER -