Interobserver variability by pathologists in the distinction between cellular fibroadenomas and phyllodes tumors

Thomas J. Lawton, Geza Acs, Pedram Argani, Gelareh Farshid, Michael Gilcrease, Neal Goldstein, Frederick Koerner, J. Jordi Rowe, Melinda Sanders, Sejal M Shah, Carol Reynolds

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

35 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Fibroepithelial lesions with cellular stroma are frequently termed cellular fibroadenomas although criteria for distinguishing them from a phyllodes tumor are vague and subjective. However, the clinical implications and surgical management for these 2 lesions may be different. We randomly selected 21 cases of fibroepithelial lesions sent in consultation to the senior author that were challenging to classify as cellular fibroadenoma or phyllodes tumor. One to 2 representative slides of each case along with patient age were sent to 10 pathologists who specialize in breast pathology. The World Health Organization criteria for phyllodes tumors and a diagnosis form were included with the study set. For the purposes of data reporting, fibroadenoma and cellular fibroadenoma are considered together. In only 2 cases was there uniform agreement as to whether the tumor represented a fibroadenoma or phyllodes tumor. Of the remaining 19 cases, if the diagnoses of fibroadenoma and benign phyllodes tumor were combined and separated from borderline and malignant phyllodes tumors, there was 100% agreement in 53% of cases and 90% agreement in 79% of cases. This study highlights the difficulty that exists in distinguishing some cellular fibroadenomas from phyllodes tumors even for pathologists who specialize in breast pathology. However, there appears to be considerable agreement when cellular fibroadenomas and benign phyllodes tumors are distinguished from borderline and malignant phyllodes tumors. Further studies are needed to determine if there is a clinically significant difference between cellular fibroadenomas and benign phyllodes tumors and how to better distinguish them from borderline and malignant phyllodes tumors.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)695-698
Number of pages4
JournalInternational Journal of Surgical Pathology
Volume22
Issue number8
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 10 2014

Fingerprint

Phyllodes Tumor
Fibroadenoma
Observer Variation
Breast
Pathologists
Pathology
Research Design
Referral and Consultation

Keywords

  • cellular fibroadenoma
  • fibroepithelial lesion
  • phyllodes tumor

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Anatomy
  • Pathology and Forensic Medicine
  • Surgery

Cite this

Interobserver variability by pathologists in the distinction between cellular fibroadenomas and phyllodes tumors. / Lawton, Thomas J.; Acs, Geza; Argani, Pedram; Farshid, Gelareh; Gilcrease, Michael; Goldstein, Neal; Koerner, Frederick; Rowe, J. Jordi; Sanders, Melinda; Shah, Sejal M; Reynolds, Carol.

In: International Journal of Surgical Pathology, Vol. 22, No. 8, 10.12.2014, p. 695-698.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Lawton, TJ, Acs, G, Argani, P, Farshid, G, Gilcrease, M, Goldstein, N, Koerner, F, Rowe, JJ, Sanders, M, Shah, SM & Reynolds, C 2014, 'Interobserver variability by pathologists in the distinction between cellular fibroadenomas and phyllodes tumors', International Journal of Surgical Pathology, vol. 22, no. 8, pp. 695-698. https://doi.org/10.1177/1066896914548763
Lawton, Thomas J. ; Acs, Geza ; Argani, Pedram ; Farshid, Gelareh ; Gilcrease, Michael ; Goldstein, Neal ; Koerner, Frederick ; Rowe, J. Jordi ; Sanders, Melinda ; Shah, Sejal M ; Reynolds, Carol. / Interobserver variability by pathologists in the distinction between cellular fibroadenomas and phyllodes tumors. In: International Journal of Surgical Pathology. 2014 ; Vol. 22, No. 8. pp. 695-698.
@article{957afffc00734ee6b49ce3bc3f705724,
title = "Interobserver variability by pathologists in the distinction between cellular fibroadenomas and phyllodes tumors",
abstract = "Fibroepithelial lesions with cellular stroma are frequently termed cellular fibroadenomas although criteria for distinguishing them from a phyllodes tumor are vague and subjective. However, the clinical implications and surgical management for these 2 lesions may be different. We randomly selected 21 cases of fibroepithelial lesions sent in consultation to the senior author that were challenging to classify as cellular fibroadenoma or phyllodes tumor. One to 2 representative slides of each case along with patient age were sent to 10 pathologists who specialize in breast pathology. The World Health Organization criteria for phyllodes tumors and a diagnosis form were included with the study set. For the purposes of data reporting, fibroadenoma and cellular fibroadenoma are considered together. In only 2 cases was there uniform agreement as to whether the tumor represented a fibroadenoma or phyllodes tumor. Of the remaining 19 cases, if the diagnoses of fibroadenoma and benign phyllodes tumor were combined and separated from borderline and malignant phyllodes tumors, there was 100{\%} agreement in 53{\%} of cases and 90{\%} agreement in 79{\%} of cases. This study highlights the difficulty that exists in distinguishing some cellular fibroadenomas from phyllodes tumors even for pathologists who specialize in breast pathology. However, there appears to be considerable agreement when cellular fibroadenomas and benign phyllodes tumors are distinguished from borderline and malignant phyllodes tumors. Further studies are needed to determine if there is a clinically significant difference between cellular fibroadenomas and benign phyllodes tumors and how to better distinguish them from borderline and malignant phyllodes tumors.",
keywords = "cellular fibroadenoma, fibroepithelial lesion, phyllodes tumor",
author = "Lawton, {Thomas J.} and Geza Acs and Pedram Argani and Gelareh Farshid and Michael Gilcrease and Neal Goldstein and Frederick Koerner and Rowe, {J. Jordi} and Melinda Sanders and Shah, {Sejal M} and Carol Reynolds",
year = "2014",
month = "12",
day = "10",
doi = "10.1177/1066896914548763",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "22",
pages = "695--698",
journal = "International Journal of Surgical Pathology",
issn = "1066-8969",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Inc.",
number = "8",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Interobserver variability by pathologists in the distinction between cellular fibroadenomas and phyllodes tumors

AU - Lawton, Thomas J.

AU - Acs, Geza

AU - Argani, Pedram

AU - Farshid, Gelareh

AU - Gilcrease, Michael

AU - Goldstein, Neal

AU - Koerner, Frederick

AU - Rowe, J. Jordi

AU - Sanders, Melinda

AU - Shah, Sejal M

AU - Reynolds, Carol

PY - 2014/12/10

Y1 - 2014/12/10

N2 - Fibroepithelial lesions with cellular stroma are frequently termed cellular fibroadenomas although criteria for distinguishing them from a phyllodes tumor are vague and subjective. However, the clinical implications and surgical management for these 2 lesions may be different. We randomly selected 21 cases of fibroepithelial lesions sent in consultation to the senior author that were challenging to classify as cellular fibroadenoma or phyllodes tumor. One to 2 representative slides of each case along with patient age were sent to 10 pathologists who specialize in breast pathology. The World Health Organization criteria for phyllodes tumors and a diagnosis form were included with the study set. For the purposes of data reporting, fibroadenoma and cellular fibroadenoma are considered together. In only 2 cases was there uniform agreement as to whether the tumor represented a fibroadenoma or phyllodes tumor. Of the remaining 19 cases, if the diagnoses of fibroadenoma and benign phyllodes tumor were combined and separated from borderline and malignant phyllodes tumors, there was 100% agreement in 53% of cases and 90% agreement in 79% of cases. This study highlights the difficulty that exists in distinguishing some cellular fibroadenomas from phyllodes tumors even for pathologists who specialize in breast pathology. However, there appears to be considerable agreement when cellular fibroadenomas and benign phyllodes tumors are distinguished from borderline and malignant phyllodes tumors. Further studies are needed to determine if there is a clinically significant difference between cellular fibroadenomas and benign phyllodes tumors and how to better distinguish them from borderline and malignant phyllodes tumors.

AB - Fibroepithelial lesions with cellular stroma are frequently termed cellular fibroadenomas although criteria for distinguishing them from a phyllodes tumor are vague and subjective. However, the clinical implications and surgical management for these 2 lesions may be different. We randomly selected 21 cases of fibroepithelial lesions sent in consultation to the senior author that were challenging to classify as cellular fibroadenoma or phyllodes tumor. One to 2 representative slides of each case along with patient age were sent to 10 pathologists who specialize in breast pathology. The World Health Organization criteria for phyllodes tumors and a diagnosis form were included with the study set. For the purposes of data reporting, fibroadenoma and cellular fibroadenoma are considered together. In only 2 cases was there uniform agreement as to whether the tumor represented a fibroadenoma or phyllodes tumor. Of the remaining 19 cases, if the diagnoses of fibroadenoma and benign phyllodes tumor were combined and separated from borderline and malignant phyllodes tumors, there was 100% agreement in 53% of cases and 90% agreement in 79% of cases. This study highlights the difficulty that exists in distinguishing some cellular fibroadenomas from phyllodes tumors even for pathologists who specialize in breast pathology. However, there appears to be considerable agreement when cellular fibroadenomas and benign phyllodes tumors are distinguished from borderline and malignant phyllodes tumors. Further studies are needed to determine if there is a clinically significant difference between cellular fibroadenomas and benign phyllodes tumors and how to better distinguish them from borderline and malignant phyllodes tumors.

KW - cellular fibroadenoma

KW - fibroepithelial lesion

KW - phyllodes tumor

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84916241288&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84916241288&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/1066896914548763

DO - 10.1177/1066896914548763

M3 - Article

C2 - 25161205

AN - SCOPUS:84916241288

VL - 22

SP - 695

EP - 698

JO - International Journal of Surgical Pathology

JF - International Journal of Surgical Pathology

SN - 1066-8969

IS - 8

ER -