Endoscopic variceal ligation is superior to combined ligation and sclerotherapy for esophageal varices: A multicenter prospective randomized trial

Zahid A. Saeed, Gregory V. Stiegmann, Francisco C Ramirez, R. Mathew Reveille, John S. Goff, Kenneth S. Hepps, Rhonda A. Cole

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

118 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Patients who have bled from varices remain at risk for rebleeding. There is interest in methods that would enable rapid eradication of varices. The present trial was designed to study whether combining ligation with sclerotherapy will allow quicker eradication of varices than either modality alone. Patients with bleeding esophageal varices were randomized into ligation or combination therapy groups. Patients in the ligation group were treated with endoscopic rubber band ligation alone. In combination group patients, each variceal column was ligated distally and 1 mL of ethanolamine was injected proximal to each ligated site. Subsequent treatment sessions were at 7- to 14-day intervals until varices were eradicated. The clinical and endoscopic characteristics of 25 patients in the ligation group were similar to those of 22 patients in the combination group. Follow-up was up to 30 months. Active bleeding was controlled in 100% of patients in the ligation group and 75% of those in combination group (P = NS). It took 3.3 ± .4 (range, 1-7) sessions to eradicate varices with ligation and 4.1 ± .6 (1-7) with combination therapy (P = NS). Survival (four deaths in ligation group, 8 in combination group), rebleeding rate (25% vs. 36%), and varix recurrence (16% vs. 23%) also were similar. There were more complications with combination therapy, including deep ulcers (65% vs. 20%; P < .05); dysphagia (30% vs. 0%; P < .05), with three strictures requiring dilation; and pain (30% vs. 10%; P = NS). Our results show that sclerotherapy combined with ligation offers no benefit over ligation alone. The higher complication rate with combination therapy does not warrant this approach.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)71-74
Number of pages4
JournalHepatology
Volume25
Issue number1
StatePublished - Jan 1997
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Sclerotherapy
Esophageal and Gastric Varices
Ligation
Varicose Veins
Hemorrhage
Ethanolamine
Rubber
Therapeutics
Deglutition Disorders
Group Psychotherapy
Ulcer
Dilatation
Pathologic Constriction
Recurrence
Pain

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Hepatology

Cite this

Saeed, Z. A., Stiegmann, G. V., Ramirez, F. C., Reveille, R. M., Goff, J. S., Hepps, K. S., & Cole, R. A. (1997). Endoscopic variceal ligation is superior to combined ligation and sclerotherapy for esophageal varices: A multicenter prospective randomized trial. Hepatology, 25(1), 71-74.

Endoscopic variceal ligation is superior to combined ligation and sclerotherapy for esophageal varices : A multicenter prospective randomized trial. / Saeed, Zahid A.; Stiegmann, Gregory V.; Ramirez, Francisco C; Reveille, R. Mathew; Goff, John S.; Hepps, Kenneth S.; Cole, Rhonda A.

In: Hepatology, Vol. 25, No. 1, 01.1997, p. 71-74.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Saeed, Zahid A. ; Stiegmann, Gregory V. ; Ramirez, Francisco C ; Reveille, R. Mathew ; Goff, John S. ; Hepps, Kenneth S. ; Cole, Rhonda A. / Endoscopic variceal ligation is superior to combined ligation and sclerotherapy for esophageal varices : A multicenter prospective randomized trial. In: Hepatology. 1997 ; Vol. 25, No. 1. pp. 71-74.
@article{7a951abe57cd47a08c356ee220b81e9c,
title = "Endoscopic variceal ligation is superior to combined ligation and sclerotherapy for esophageal varices: A multicenter prospective randomized trial",
abstract = "Patients who have bled from varices remain at risk for rebleeding. There is interest in methods that would enable rapid eradication of varices. The present trial was designed to study whether combining ligation with sclerotherapy will allow quicker eradication of varices than either modality alone. Patients with bleeding esophageal varices were randomized into ligation or combination therapy groups. Patients in the ligation group were treated with endoscopic rubber band ligation alone. In combination group patients, each variceal column was ligated distally and 1 mL of ethanolamine was injected proximal to each ligated site. Subsequent treatment sessions were at 7- to 14-day intervals until varices were eradicated. The clinical and endoscopic characteristics of 25 patients in the ligation group were similar to those of 22 patients in the combination group. Follow-up was up to 30 months. Active bleeding was controlled in 100{\%} of patients in the ligation group and 75{\%} of those in combination group (P = NS). It took 3.3 ± .4 (range, 1-7) sessions to eradicate varices with ligation and 4.1 ± .6 (1-7) with combination therapy (P = NS). Survival (four deaths in ligation group, 8 in combination group), rebleeding rate (25{\%} vs. 36{\%}), and varix recurrence (16{\%} vs. 23{\%}) also were similar. There were more complications with combination therapy, including deep ulcers (65{\%} vs. 20{\%}; P < .05); dysphagia (30{\%} vs. 0{\%}; P < .05), with three strictures requiring dilation; and pain (30{\%} vs. 10{\%}; P = NS). Our results show that sclerotherapy combined with ligation offers no benefit over ligation alone. The higher complication rate with combination therapy does not warrant this approach.",
author = "Saeed, {Zahid A.} and Stiegmann, {Gregory V.} and Ramirez, {Francisco C} and Reveille, {R. Mathew} and Goff, {John S.} and Hepps, {Kenneth S.} and Cole, {Rhonda A.}",
year = "1997",
month = "1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "25",
pages = "71--74",
journal = "Hepatology",
issn = "0270-9139",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Ltd",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Endoscopic variceal ligation is superior to combined ligation and sclerotherapy for esophageal varices

T2 - A multicenter prospective randomized trial

AU - Saeed, Zahid A.

AU - Stiegmann, Gregory V.

AU - Ramirez, Francisco C

AU - Reveille, R. Mathew

AU - Goff, John S.

AU - Hepps, Kenneth S.

AU - Cole, Rhonda A.

PY - 1997/1

Y1 - 1997/1

N2 - Patients who have bled from varices remain at risk for rebleeding. There is interest in methods that would enable rapid eradication of varices. The present trial was designed to study whether combining ligation with sclerotherapy will allow quicker eradication of varices than either modality alone. Patients with bleeding esophageal varices were randomized into ligation or combination therapy groups. Patients in the ligation group were treated with endoscopic rubber band ligation alone. In combination group patients, each variceal column was ligated distally and 1 mL of ethanolamine was injected proximal to each ligated site. Subsequent treatment sessions were at 7- to 14-day intervals until varices were eradicated. The clinical and endoscopic characteristics of 25 patients in the ligation group were similar to those of 22 patients in the combination group. Follow-up was up to 30 months. Active bleeding was controlled in 100% of patients in the ligation group and 75% of those in combination group (P = NS). It took 3.3 ± .4 (range, 1-7) sessions to eradicate varices with ligation and 4.1 ± .6 (1-7) with combination therapy (P = NS). Survival (four deaths in ligation group, 8 in combination group), rebleeding rate (25% vs. 36%), and varix recurrence (16% vs. 23%) also were similar. There were more complications with combination therapy, including deep ulcers (65% vs. 20%; P < .05); dysphagia (30% vs. 0%; P < .05), with three strictures requiring dilation; and pain (30% vs. 10%; P = NS). Our results show that sclerotherapy combined with ligation offers no benefit over ligation alone. The higher complication rate with combination therapy does not warrant this approach.

AB - Patients who have bled from varices remain at risk for rebleeding. There is interest in methods that would enable rapid eradication of varices. The present trial was designed to study whether combining ligation with sclerotherapy will allow quicker eradication of varices than either modality alone. Patients with bleeding esophageal varices were randomized into ligation or combination therapy groups. Patients in the ligation group were treated with endoscopic rubber band ligation alone. In combination group patients, each variceal column was ligated distally and 1 mL of ethanolamine was injected proximal to each ligated site. Subsequent treatment sessions were at 7- to 14-day intervals until varices were eradicated. The clinical and endoscopic characteristics of 25 patients in the ligation group were similar to those of 22 patients in the combination group. Follow-up was up to 30 months. Active bleeding was controlled in 100% of patients in the ligation group and 75% of those in combination group (P = NS). It took 3.3 ± .4 (range, 1-7) sessions to eradicate varices with ligation and 4.1 ± .6 (1-7) with combination therapy (P = NS). Survival (four deaths in ligation group, 8 in combination group), rebleeding rate (25% vs. 36%), and varix recurrence (16% vs. 23%) also were similar. There were more complications with combination therapy, including deep ulcers (65% vs. 20%; P < .05); dysphagia (30% vs. 0%; P < .05), with three strictures requiring dilation; and pain (30% vs. 10%; P = NS). Our results show that sclerotherapy combined with ligation offers no benefit over ligation alone. The higher complication rate with combination therapy does not warrant this approach.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0031030731&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0031030731&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 8985267

AN - SCOPUS:0031030731

VL - 25

SP - 71

EP - 74

JO - Hepatology

JF - Hepatology

SN - 0270-9139

IS - 1

ER -