Discordant diagnosis of lower extremity peripheral artery disease using American Heart Association postexercise guidelines

Guillaume Mahe, Amy W. Pollak, David A. Liedl, Kevin P. Cohoon, Charlene Mc Carter, Thom W Rooke, Paul W. Wennberg, Alejandro Lopez Suarez

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

22 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

To determine whether postexercise criteria for peripheral artery disease (PAD) diagnosis recommended by the American Heart Association (AHA) identifies the same group of PAD patients. Diagnosis of PAD is performed using ankle-brachial index at rest (resting-ABI). When resting-ABI is not contributive, an AHA scientific statement recommend to use 1 of 2 following criteria: a postexercise ABI decrease of greater than 20% or a postexercise ankle pressure decrease of greater than 30 mm Hg. Between 1996 and 2012, 31,663 consecutive patients underwent lower-extremity arterial study at Mayo Clinic. Among them, only unique patients who had exercise treadmill testing were analyzed. In this retrospective analysis, resting-ABI, postexercise ABI, and postexercise decrease of ankle pressure measured at 1-minute were measured in each patient. We conducted an analysis of agreement between postexercise criteria expressing the agreement separately for the positive and the negative ratings. Twelve thousand three hundred twelve consecutive patients were studied with a mean age of 67 ± 12 years, 61% male. According to resting-ABI, 4317 (35%) patients had PAD. In the whole population, if a clinician diagnoses "PAD" with 1 postexercise criterion, the probability that other clinicians would also diagnose "PAD" is 74.3%. If a clinician diagnoses "no PAD", the probability that other clinicians would also diagnose "no PAD" is 82.4%. In the patients to be of potential benefit from treadmill test when the resting-ABI > 0.90, if a clinician diagnoses "PAD" with 1 postexercise criterion, the probability that other clinicians would also diagnose "PAD" is 58.4% whereas if a clinician diagnoses "no PAD," the probability that other clinicians would also diagnose "no PAD" is 87.5%. Postexercise criteria do not identify the same group of PAD patients. In our opinion, postexercise criteria to define PAD deserve additional study.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article numbere1277
JournalMedicine (United Kingdom)
Volume94
Issue number31
DOIs
StatePublished - Aug 1 2015

Fingerprint

Peripheral Arterial Disease
Lower Extremity
Guidelines
Ankle
American Heart Association
Pressure
Ankle Brachial Index
Exercise Test

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Medicine(all)

Cite this

Discordant diagnosis of lower extremity peripheral artery disease using American Heart Association postexercise guidelines. / Mahe, Guillaume; Pollak, Amy W.; Liedl, David A.; Cohoon, Kevin P.; Carter, Charlene Mc; Rooke, Thom W; Wennberg, Paul W.; Suarez, Alejandro Lopez.

In: Medicine (United Kingdom), Vol. 94, No. 31, e1277, 01.08.2015.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Mahe, Guillaume ; Pollak, Amy W. ; Liedl, David A. ; Cohoon, Kevin P. ; Carter, Charlene Mc ; Rooke, Thom W ; Wennberg, Paul W. ; Suarez, Alejandro Lopez. / Discordant diagnosis of lower extremity peripheral artery disease using American Heart Association postexercise guidelines. In: Medicine (United Kingdom). 2015 ; Vol. 94, No. 31.
@article{6d7916395f6b4231b5178ca34c6be8c6,
title = "Discordant diagnosis of lower extremity peripheral artery disease using American Heart Association postexercise guidelines",
abstract = "To determine whether postexercise criteria for peripheral artery disease (PAD) diagnosis recommended by the American Heart Association (AHA) identifies the same group of PAD patients. Diagnosis of PAD is performed using ankle-brachial index at rest (resting-ABI). When resting-ABI is not contributive, an AHA scientific statement recommend to use 1 of 2 following criteria: a postexercise ABI decrease of greater than 20{\%} or a postexercise ankle pressure decrease of greater than 30 mm Hg. Between 1996 and 2012, 31,663 consecutive patients underwent lower-extremity arterial study at Mayo Clinic. Among them, only unique patients who had exercise treadmill testing were analyzed. In this retrospective analysis, resting-ABI, postexercise ABI, and postexercise decrease of ankle pressure measured at 1-minute were measured in each patient. We conducted an analysis of agreement between postexercise criteria expressing the agreement separately for the positive and the negative ratings. Twelve thousand three hundred twelve consecutive patients were studied with a mean age of 67 ± 12 years, 61{\%} male. According to resting-ABI, 4317 (35{\%}) patients had PAD. In the whole population, if a clinician diagnoses {"}PAD{"} with 1 postexercise criterion, the probability that other clinicians would also diagnose {"}PAD{"} is 74.3{\%}. If a clinician diagnoses {"}no PAD{"}, the probability that other clinicians would also diagnose {"}no PAD{"} is 82.4{\%}. In the patients to be of potential benefit from treadmill test when the resting-ABI > 0.90, if a clinician diagnoses {"}PAD{"} with 1 postexercise criterion, the probability that other clinicians would also diagnose {"}PAD{"} is 58.4{\%} whereas if a clinician diagnoses {"}no PAD,{"} the probability that other clinicians would also diagnose {"}no PAD{"} is 87.5{\%}. Postexercise criteria do not identify the same group of PAD patients. In our opinion, postexercise criteria to define PAD deserve additional study.",
author = "Guillaume Mahe and Pollak, {Amy W.} and Liedl, {David A.} and Cohoon, {Kevin P.} and Carter, {Charlene Mc} and Rooke, {Thom W} and Wennberg, {Paul W.} and Suarez, {Alejandro Lopez}",
year = "2015",
month = "8",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1097/MD.0000000000001277",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "94",
journal = "Medicine (United States)",
issn = "1357-3039",
publisher = "Lippincott Williams and Wilkins",
number = "31",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Discordant diagnosis of lower extremity peripheral artery disease using American Heart Association postexercise guidelines

AU - Mahe, Guillaume

AU - Pollak, Amy W.

AU - Liedl, David A.

AU - Cohoon, Kevin P.

AU - Carter, Charlene Mc

AU - Rooke, Thom W

AU - Wennberg, Paul W.

AU - Suarez, Alejandro Lopez

PY - 2015/8/1

Y1 - 2015/8/1

N2 - To determine whether postexercise criteria for peripheral artery disease (PAD) diagnosis recommended by the American Heart Association (AHA) identifies the same group of PAD patients. Diagnosis of PAD is performed using ankle-brachial index at rest (resting-ABI). When resting-ABI is not contributive, an AHA scientific statement recommend to use 1 of 2 following criteria: a postexercise ABI decrease of greater than 20% or a postexercise ankle pressure decrease of greater than 30 mm Hg. Between 1996 and 2012, 31,663 consecutive patients underwent lower-extremity arterial study at Mayo Clinic. Among them, only unique patients who had exercise treadmill testing were analyzed. In this retrospective analysis, resting-ABI, postexercise ABI, and postexercise decrease of ankle pressure measured at 1-minute were measured in each patient. We conducted an analysis of agreement between postexercise criteria expressing the agreement separately for the positive and the negative ratings. Twelve thousand three hundred twelve consecutive patients were studied with a mean age of 67 ± 12 years, 61% male. According to resting-ABI, 4317 (35%) patients had PAD. In the whole population, if a clinician diagnoses "PAD" with 1 postexercise criterion, the probability that other clinicians would also diagnose "PAD" is 74.3%. If a clinician diagnoses "no PAD", the probability that other clinicians would also diagnose "no PAD" is 82.4%. In the patients to be of potential benefit from treadmill test when the resting-ABI > 0.90, if a clinician diagnoses "PAD" with 1 postexercise criterion, the probability that other clinicians would also diagnose "PAD" is 58.4% whereas if a clinician diagnoses "no PAD," the probability that other clinicians would also diagnose "no PAD" is 87.5%. Postexercise criteria do not identify the same group of PAD patients. In our opinion, postexercise criteria to define PAD deserve additional study.

AB - To determine whether postexercise criteria for peripheral artery disease (PAD) diagnosis recommended by the American Heart Association (AHA) identifies the same group of PAD patients. Diagnosis of PAD is performed using ankle-brachial index at rest (resting-ABI). When resting-ABI is not contributive, an AHA scientific statement recommend to use 1 of 2 following criteria: a postexercise ABI decrease of greater than 20% or a postexercise ankle pressure decrease of greater than 30 mm Hg. Between 1996 and 2012, 31,663 consecutive patients underwent lower-extremity arterial study at Mayo Clinic. Among them, only unique patients who had exercise treadmill testing were analyzed. In this retrospective analysis, resting-ABI, postexercise ABI, and postexercise decrease of ankle pressure measured at 1-minute were measured in each patient. We conducted an analysis of agreement between postexercise criteria expressing the agreement separately for the positive and the negative ratings. Twelve thousand three hundred twelve consecutive patients were studied with a mean age of 67 ± 12 years, 61% male. According to resting-ABI, 4317 (35%) patients had PAD. In the whole population, if a clinician diagnoses "PAD" with 1 postexercise criterion, the probability that other clinicians would also diagnose "PAD" is 74.3%. If a clinician diagnoses "no PAD", the probability that other clinicians would also diagnose "no PAD" is 82.4%. In the patients to be of potential benefit from treadmill test when the resting-ABI > 0.90, if a clinician diagnoses "PAD" with 1 postexercise criterion, the probability that other clinicians would also diagnose "PAD" is 58.4% whereas if a clinician diagnoses "no PAD," the probability that other clinicians would also diagnose "no PAD" is 87.5%. Postexercise criteria do not identify the same group of PAD patients. In our opinion, postexercise criteria to define PAD deserve additional study.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84942434302&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84942434302&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1097/MD.0000000000001277

DO - 10.1097/MD.0000000000001277

M3 - Article

C2 - 26252297

AN - SCOPUS:84942434302

VL - 94

JO - Medicine (United States)

JF - Medicine (United States)

SN - 1357-3039

IS - 31

M1 - e1277

ER -