A novel and fast method for proton range verification using a step wedge and 2D scintillator

Jiajian Shen, Bryce C. Allred, Daniel G. Robertson, Wei Liu, Terence T. Sio, Nicholas B. Remmes, Sameer R. Keole, Martin Bues

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Purpose: To implement and evaluate a novel and fast method for proton range verification by using a planar scintillator and step wedge. Methods: A homogenous proton pencil beam plan with 35 energies was designed and delivered to a 2D flat scintillator with a step wedge. The measurement was repeated 15 times (3 different days, 5 times per day). The scintillator image was smoothed, the Bragg peak and distal fall off regions were fitted by an analytical equation, and the proton range was calculated using simple trigonometry. The accuracy of this method was verified by comparing the measured ranges to those obtained using an ionization chamber and a scanning water tank, the gold standard. The reproducibility was evaluated by comparing the ranges over 15 repeated measurements. The sensitivity was evaluated by delivering to same beam to the system with a film inserted under the wedge. Results: The range accuracy of all 35 proton energies measured over 3 days was within 0.2 mm. The reproducibility in 15 repeated measurements for all 35 proton ranges was ±0.045 mm. The sensitivity to range variation is 0.1 mm for the worst case. This efficient procedure permits measurement of 35 proton ranges in less than 3 min. The automated data processing produces results immediately. The setup of this system took less than 5 min. The time saving by this new method is about two orders of magnitude when compared with the time for water tank range measurements. Conclusions: A novel method using a scintillator with a step wedge to measure the proton range was implemented and evaluated. This novel method is fast and sensitive, and the proton range measured by this method was accurate and highly reproducible.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)4409-4414
Number of pages6
JournalMedical Physics
Volume44
Issue number9
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 1 2017

Fingerprint

Protons
Water

Keywords

  • proton pencil beam scanning
  • proton range measurements
  • quality assurance
  • scintillator
  • wedge

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biophysics
  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging

Cite this

Shen, J., Allred, B. C., Robertson, D. G., Liu, W., Sio, T. T., Remmes, N. B., ... Bues, M. (2017). A novel and fast method for proton range verification using a step wedge and 2D scintillator. Medical Physics, 44(9), 4409-4414. https://doi.org/10.1002/mp.12439

A novel and fast method for proton range verification using a step wedge and 2D scintillator. / Shen, Jiajian; Allred, Bryce C.; Robertson, Daniel G.; Liu, Wei; Sio, Terence T.; Remmes, Nicholas B.; Keole, Sameer R.; Bues, Martin.

In: Medical Physics, Vol. 44, No. 9, 01.09.2017, p. 4409-4414.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Shen, J, Allred, BC, Robertson, DG, Liu, W, Sio, TT, Remmes, NB, Keole, SR & Bues, M 2017, 'A novel and fast method for proton range verification using a step wedge and 2D scintillator', Medical Physics, vol. 44, no. 9, pp. 4409-4414. https://doi.org/10.1002/mp.12439
Shen, Jiajian ; Allred, Bryce C. ; Robertson, Daniel G. ; Liu, Wei ; Sio, Terence T. ; Remmes, Nicholas B. ; Keole, Sameer R. ; Bues, Martin. / A novel and fast method for proton range verification using a step wedge and 2D scintillator. In: Medical Physics. 2017 ; Vol. 44, No. 9. pp. 4409-4414.
@article{e0595202ba84406e9d649070bff6a918,
title = "A novel and fast method for proton range verification using a step wedge and 2D scintillator",
abstract = "Purpose: To implement and evaluate a novel and fast method for proton range verification by using a planar scintillator and step wedge. Methods: A homogenous proton pencil beam plan with 35 energies was designed and delivered to a 2D flat scintillator with a step wedge. The measurement was repeated 15 times (3 different days, 5 times per day). The scintillator image was smoothed, the Bragg peak and distal fall off regions were fitted by an analytical equation, and the proton range was calculated using simple trigonometry. The accuracy of this method was verified by comparing the measured ranges to those obtained using an ionization chamber and a scanning water tank, the gold standard. The reproducibility was evaluated by comparing the ranges over 15 repeated measurements. The sensitivity was evaluated by delivering to same beam to the system with a film inserted under the wedge. Results: The range accuracy of all 35 proton energies measured over 3 days was within 0.2 mm. The reproducibility in 15 repeated measurements for all 35 proton ranges was ±0.045 mm. The sensitivity to range variation is 0.1 mm for the worst case. This efficient procedure permits measurement of 35 proton ranges in less than 3 min. The automated data processing produces results immediately. The setup of this system took less than 5 min. The time saving by this new method is about two orders of magnitude when compared with the time for water tank range measurements. Conclusions: A novel method using a scintillator with a step wedge to measure the proton range was implemented and evaluated. This novel method is fast and sensitive, and the proton range measured by this method was accurate and highly reproducible.",
keywords = "proton pencil beam scanning, proton range measurements, quality assurance, scintillator, wedge",
author = "Jiajian Shen and Allred, {Bryce C.} and Robertson, {Daniel G.} and Wei Liu and Sio, {Terence T.} and Remmes, {Nicholas B.} and Keole, {Sameer R.} and Martin Bues",
year = "2017",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/mp.12439",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "44",
pages = "4409--4414",
journal = "Medical Physics",
issn = "0094-2405",
publisher = "AAPM - American Association of Physicists in Medicine",
number = "9",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A novel and fast method for proton range verification using a step wedge and 2D scintillator

AU - Shen, Jiajian

AU - Allred, Bryce C.

AU - Robertson, Daniel G.

AU - Liu, Wei

AU - Sio, Terence T.

AU - Remmes, Nicholas B.

AU - Keole, Sameer R.

AU - Bues, Martin

PY - 2017/9/1

Y1 - 2017/9/1

N2 - Purpose: To implement and evaluate a novel and fast method for proton range verification by using a planar scintillator and step wedge. Methods: A homogenous proton pencil beam plan with 35 energies was designed and delivered to a 2D flat scintillator with a step wedge. The measurement was repeated 15 times (3 different days, 5 times per day). The scintillator image was smoothed, the Bragg peak and distal fall off regions were fitted by an analytical equation, and the proton range was calculated using simple trigonometry. The accuracy of this method was verified by comparing the measured ranges to those obtained using an ionization chamber and a scanning water tank, the gold standard. The reproducibility was evaluated by comparing the ranges over 15 repeated measurements. The sensitivity was evaluated by delivering to same beam to the system with a film inserted under the wedge. Results: The range accuracy of all 35 proton energies measured over 3 days was within 0.2 mm. The reproducibility in 15 repeated measurements for all 35 proton ranges was ±0.045 mm. The sensitivity to range variation is 0.1 mm for the worst case. This efficient procedure permits measurement of 35 proton ranges in less than 3 min. The automated data processing produces results immediately. The setup of this system took less than 5 min. The time saving by this new method is about two orders of magnitude when compared with the time for water tank range measurements. Conclusions: A novel method using a scintillator with a step wedge to measure the proton range was implemented and evaluated. This novel method is fast and sensitive, and the proton range measured by this method was accurate and highly reproducible.

AB - Purpose: To implement and evaluate a novel and fast method for proton range verification by using a planar scintillator and step wedge. Methods: A homogenous proton pencil beam plan with 35 energies was designed and delivered to a 2D flat scintillator with a step wedge. The measurement was repeated 15 times (3 different days, 5 times per day). The scintillator image was smoothed, the Bragg peak and distal fall off regions were fitted by an analytical equation, and the proton range was calculated using simple trigonometry. The accuracy of this method was verified by comparing the measured ranges to those obtained using an ionization chamber and a scanning water tank, the gold standard. The reproducibility was evaluated by comparing the ranges over 15 repeated measurements. The sensitivity was evaluated by delivering to same beam to the system with a film inserted under the wedge. Results: The range accuracy of all 35 proton energies measured over 3 days was within 0.2 mm. The reproducibility in 15 repeated measurements for all 35 proton ranges was ±0.045 mm. The sensitivity to range variation is 0.1 mm for the worst case. This efficient procedure permits measurement of 35 proton ranges in less than 3 min. The automated data processing produces results immediately. The setup of this system took less than 5 min. The time saving by this new method is about two orders of magnitude when compared with the time for water tank range measurements. Conclusions: A novel method using a scintillator with a step wedge to measure the proton range was implemented and evaluated. This novel method is fast and sensitive, and the proton range measured by this method was accurate and highly reproducible.

KW - proton pencil beam scanning

KW - proton range measurements

KW - quality assurance

KW - scintillator

KW - wedge

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85026473988&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85026473988&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/mp.12439

DO - 10.1002/mp.12439

M3 - Article

C2 - 28665529

AN - SCOPUS:85026473988

VL - 44

SP - 4409

EP - 4414

JO - Medical Physics

JF - Medical Physics

SN - 0094-2405

IS - 9

ER -