A Meta-analysis to Guide the Enhancement of CBT for Childhood Anxiety: Exposure Over Anxiety Management

Stephen P.H. Whiteside, Leslie A. Sim, Allison S. Morrow, Wigdan H. Farah, Daniel R. Hilliker, M. Hassan Murad, Zhen Wang

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Cognitive behavior therapy (CBT) is the most empirically supported therapy for childhood anxiety disorders (CADs) but has not reliably outperformed other credible interventions. The current study used meta-analysis to examine the frequency with which the most common treatment components are included in outcome studies and the relation of these components to symptom improvement. Seventy-five studies were identified that included youth with an anxiety disorder treated with CBT or a comparison condition. The protocols for the 111 CBT conditions generally consisted of 12, 1-h sessions delivered to the child with minimal parent inclusion. A greater amount of in-session exposure was related to significantly larger effect sizes between CBT and waitlist control across reporters (− 0.12 to − 0.15; P’s <.05) and from pre- to post-treatment for child report (−.06; P <.01). Compared to treatments that omitted relaxation, treatments that included relaxation strategies were associated with significantly smaller pre- to post-treatment effect sizes across reporters (0.38 to 0.80; P’s <.05). The current study suggests that CBT protocols for CADs that emphasize in-session exposure and do not include relaxation have the potential to improve the efficacy and effectiveness of therapy. Dismantling studies directly testing these hypotheses are needed.

Original languageEnglish (US)
JournalClinical Child and Family Psychology Review
DOIs
StateAccepted/In press - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

behavior therapy
Cognitive Therapy
Meta-Analysis
cognition
Anxiety
childhood
anxiety
management
reporter
Anxiety Disorders
Therapeutics
dismantling
hypothesis testing
parents
inclusion
Outcome Assessment (Health Care)

Keywords

  • Childhood anxiety disorders
  • Cognitive behavior therapy
  • Exposure therapy
  • Literature review
  • Relaxation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Pediatrics, Perinatology, and Child Health
  • Education
  • Developmental and Educational Psychology
  • Clinical Psychology
  • Psychiatry and Mental health

Cite this

A Meta-analysis to Guide the Enhancement of CBT for Childhood Anxiety : Exposure Over Anxiety Management. / Whiteside, Stephen P.H.; Sim, Leslie A.; Morrow, Allison S.; Farah, Wigdan H.; Hilliker, Daniel R.; Murad, M. Hassan; Wang, Zhen.

In: Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review, 01.01.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

@article{a3288b297f1841bb8e62d67da78feba9,
title = "A Meta-analysis to Guide the Enhancement of CBT for Childhood Anxiety: Exposure Over Anxiety Management",
abstract = "Cognitive behavior therapy (CBT) is the most empirically supported therapy for childhood anxiety disorders (CADs) but has not reliably outperformed other credible interventions. The current study used meta-analysis to examine the frequency with which the most common treatment components are included in outcome studies and the relation of these components to symptom improvement. Seventy-five studies were identified that included youth with an anxiety disorder treated with CBT or a comparison condition. The protocols for the 111 CBT conditions generally consisted of 12, 1-h sessions delivered to the child with minimal parent inclusion. A greater amount of in-session exposure was related to significantly larger effect sizes between CBT and waitlist control across reporters (− 0.12 to − 0.15; P’s <.05) and from pre- to post-treatment for child report (−.06; P <.01). Compared to treatments that omitted relaxation, treatments that included relaxation strategies were associated with significantly smaller pre- to post-treatment effect sizes across reporters (0.38 to 0.80; P’s <.05). The current study suggests that CBT protocols for CADs that emphasize in-session exposure and do not include relaxation have the potential to improve the efficacy and effectiveness of therapy. Dismantling studies directly testing these hypotheses are needed.",
keywords = "Childhood anxiety disorders, Cognitive behavior therapy, Exposure therapy, Literature review, Relaxation",
author = "Whiteside, {Stephen P.H.} and Sim, {Leslie A.} and Morrow, {Allison S.} and Farah, {Wigdan H.} and Hilliker, {Daniel R.} and Murad, {M. Hassan} and Zhen Wang",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/s10567-019-00303-2",
language = "English (US)",
journal = "Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review",
issn = "1096-4037",
publisher = "Kluwer Academic Publishers",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A Meta-analysis to Guide the Enhancement of CBT for Childhood Anxiety

T2 - Exposure Over Anxiety Management

AU - Whiteside, Stephen P.H.

AU - Sim, Leslie A.

AU - Morrow, Allison S.

AU - Farah, Wigdan H.

AU - Hilliker, Daniel R.

AU - Murad, M. Hassan

AU - Wang, Zhen

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - Cognitive behavior therapy (CBT) is the most empirically supported therapy for childhood anxiety disorders (CADs) but has not reliably outperformed other credible interventions. The current study used meta-analysis to examine the frequency with which the most common treatment components are included in outcome studies and the relation of these components to symptom improvement. Seventy-five studies were identified that included youth with an anxiety disorder treated with CBT or a comparison condition. The protocols for the 111 CBT conditions generally consisted of 12, 1-h sessions delivered to the child with minimal parent inclusion. A greater amount of in-session exposure was related to significantly larger effect sizes between CBT and waitlist control across reporters (− 0.12 to − 0.15; P’s <.05) and from pre- to post-treatment for child report (−.06; P <.01). Compared to treatments that omitted relaxation, treatments that included relaxation strategies were associated with significantly smaller pre- to post-treatment effect sizes across reporters (0.38 to 0.80; P’s <.05). The current study suggests that CBT protocols for CADs that emphasize in-session exposure and do not include relaxation have the potential to improve the efficacy and effectiveness of therapy. Dismantling studies directly testing these hypotheses are needed.

AB - Cognitive behavior therapy (CBT) is the most empirically supported therapy for childhood anxiety disorders (CADs) but has not reliably outperformed other credible interventions. The current study used meta-analysis to examine the frequency with which the most common treatment components are included in outcome studies and the relation of these components to symptom improvement. Seventy-five studies were identified that included youth with an anxiety disorder treated with CBT or a comparison condition. The protocols for the 111 CBT conditions generally consisted of 12, 1-h sessions delivered to the child with minimal parent inclusion. A greater amount of in-session exposure was related to significantly larger effect sizes between CBT and waitlist control across reporters (− 0.12 to − 0.15; P’s <.05) and from pre- to post-treatment for child report (−.06; P <.01). Compared to treatments that omitted relaxation, treatments that included relaxation strategies were associated with significantly smaller pre- to post-treatment effect sizes across reporters (0.38 to 0.80; P’s <.05). The current study suggests that CBT protocols for CADs that emphasize in-session exposure and do not include relaxation have the potential to improve the efficacy and effectiveness of therapy. Dismantling studies directly testing these hypotheses are needed.

KW - Childhood anxiety disorders

KW - Cognitive behavior therapy

KW - Exposure therapy

KW - Literature review

KW - Relaxation

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85076476420&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85076476420&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s10567-019-00303-2

DO - 10.1007/s10567-019-00303-2

M3 - Review article

AN - SCOPUS:85076476420

JO - Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review

JF - Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review

SN - 1096-4037

ER -